Author | Topic: Add: The Keel Row | |
dmcg | Posted - 08 Oct 04 - 11:44 am | |
As I cam' doon the Sandgate, The Sandgate, the Sandgate, As I cam' doon the Sandgate, I heard a lassie sing! "O weel may the keel row, The keel row, the keel row, O weel may the keel row, The ship my laddie's in." O wha's like my Johnny, So leith, so blithe, so bonny, He's foremost 'mong the mony Keel lads o' coaly Tyne. He'll set and row so tightly, Or in the dance -so sprightly- He'll cut and shuffle slightly, 'Tis true - were he not mine. He wears a blue bonnet, Blue bonnet, blue bonnet, He wears a blue bonnet, Blue bonnet, blue bonnet, A dimple in his chin. O weel may the keel row, The keel row, the keel row, O weel may the keel row, The ship my laddie's in." Source: Singing Together, Spring 1968, BBC Publications ====== For what its worth, I do not think I ever heard 'Sandgate' referred to as 'THE Sandgate' when I lived near Newcastle. In that sense at least, versions that start As I cam' thro' Sandgate, thro' Sandgate, thro' Sandgate" such as that in Bruce and Stokoe's "Northumbrian Minstrelsy" seem a better fit. Moreover, that book contains lyrics closer to those I heard occasionally at that time. In particular, the half-verse about dancing is replaced by another 'chorus' of "Weel may the Keel row, etc." The timing of this song reminds me of a strathspey, but as Bruce and Stokoe say, "This song has attained great popularity in Scotland, but we have no evidence of such favour being bestowed upon it until comparatively late in the present century." [i.e. 19th] Edited By dmcg - 08-Oct-2004 11:51:53 AM | ||
Guest Account |
Posted - 15 Jan 05 - 11:17 pm | |
From: AliPatta I have never seen the middle verse before and it doesn't seem to fit the tune. Also, "came doon the Sandgate" just doesn't scan either. "As I came through Sandgate" is the way I was taught it and I have always heard it sung in Newcastle and beyond so someone's got it wrong there. Probably the BBC luvs from the redbricks trying to make it grammatically suitable to teach around the country. This is a Newcastle song and should be left well alone by those who aren't in the know. | ||
Jon Freeman | Posted - 15 Jan 05 - 11:40 pm | |
A problem with the Singing Together books is they don't always indicate where they got the song from. The only other version of the Keel Row I have here is from The News Chronicle Song Book. That has the first half of the middle verse here but continues with Weel May The Keel Row. | ||
Jon Freeman | Posted - 15 Jan 05 - 11:58 pm | |
Several versions at the Bodleian Library but I can't find one with that middle verse. Some examples such as this example - Harding B11 (1355) do not have Sandgate at all but have "through the Cannon-gate". Jon | ||
Malcolm Douglas |
Posted - 16 Jan 05 - 01:38 am | |
The middle verse appears in Chappell, Popular Music of the Olden Time, 1859, II, 721-722. Source is not specified; he mentions Ritson's Northumberland Garland (1793) -which doesn't include it- Bell's Rhymes of the Northern Bards (1812) and "several later collections". Could be any of those. The BBC set may be from Chappell (with some mild re-writing to text and tune) or from elsewhere. "Leith", I am sure, is a typo for "leish", and "slightly" for "sightly". "AliPatta" is quite wrong to blame "BBC luvs" for what he or she thinks is a mistake. If there is really a mistake there, it was made in Northumberland (or further North; Cromeck and Cunningham both published it as a "Scottish" song) and more than 150 years ago! Perhaps he or she doesn't realise that songs of this kind exist in various forms: the one most common at a particular time is likely to be thought by many to be the only "correct" version, having the authority of print and "received wisdom". There is rather more to it than that. Edited By Malcolm Douglas - 16-Jan-2005 01:47:51 AM | ||
Mick Pearce | Posted - 16 Jan 05 - 02:10 pm | |
Stokoe in Songs Of Northern England (1893) gives the two verse version of The Keel Row (As I cam... He wears...) and follows it up with this version written by Thomas Thompson, which starts with the middle verse above, suggesting he might have written it (no other verses is common). I have heard the middle verse sung. It has "leish" as suggested by Malcolm above, but retains "sightly". Mick THE NEW KEEL ROW (Thomas Thompson)
Source: John Stokoe - Songs of Northern England, 1893 |